WordPress Theme

Posted May 28th, 2009 by Michael Janzen

Note: I’ve setup a new blog just for my theme, Basic Simplicity. I’ll also be blogging about blogging over there.

186 Responses to “WordPress Theme”

  1. mark says:

    Michael,

    Thanks for the quick and helpful reply.

    I cannot see how do we add an RSS.

    Thanks,

    Mark

  2. Michael Janzen says:

    Hi Mark,

    I suggest using a text widget in the top right of the main sidebar. You can see an example of this at http://www.tinyhousedesign.com

  3. Michael,
    thanks for the lovely template and for your help using it. For a peek: http://www.frauenrechte-rheinmain.de
    Kind regards from Frankfurt,
    Mariam

  4. Vince says:

    Hey Michael,
    Great Theme, but I have been having a hard time putting in the Google Adsense Code. Where is the best place to put this.
    Thanks.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Vince,

      Use the ‘text widget’ and paste your adsense code into it. The main reason I made so many widget regions was to serve up ads and other content effectively. The top of the sidebar is the best spot, at least on my blogs. Look at http://www.tinyhousedesign.com/ for the most optiimized layout.

      The double column ad unit (two vertical ads, 160×600 and 120×600) lower in the sidebar works great! It’s simply a hand coded table with two cells pasted into a text widget.

      Another trick (so to speak) is to put a image only 300×250 above a text only 300×250. Both ad units get similar traffic as long as you don’t have two text only and two image only together. It seems when you mix it up the ads are more likely to avoid ‘ad blindness’ improving their effectiveness.

      Good Luck!

  5. Vince says:

    Hey Michael,
    I tried pasting the code in the ‘text widget’ but nothing shows up. It just has a big empty space. Any suggestions?
    Vince

    • Michael Janzen says:

      The only thing that comes to mind is that adsense is not delivering ads or a caching plugin is turned on. To see if the javascript adsense code is getting saved and displayed view page source and scroll down to the sidebar and have a look.

  6. Vince says:

    Hey Michael,
    I was finally able to drop in the code.

    But, I have one more question: Is there anyway to move the “add comment” from just below the title of the post, to the end of the post.

    Thanks

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Vince,

      Yes it’s not hard to do. Just go to Appearance > Editor and then select the index.php file on the right.

      Look for this line of code:
      <div><?php comments_popup_link(‘Add a Comment’, ’1 Comment’, ‘% Comments’, ‘commentslink’); ?></div>

      Then move it down to just before where it says:
      </div><!–end the_content–>

  7. Judi says:

    Hi Michael –

    This is such a great theme — I just love it.

    However, I am having the toughest time getting text to wrap around my images. I’ve tried everything I can think of — but nothing works.

    I wonder if you were ever able to help Sherry with her issue and if so what was the fix?

    Thanks,

    Judi

  8. Judi says:

    oops — if you’re looking at my blog, the problem is on the About Us page.

    Thanks,

  9. Michael Janzen says:

    Hi Judi,

    When you insert the image selecting aligh right/left should allow the text to wrap.

    -Michael

  10. dls says:

    Love the theme but would like to increase the font size of the Title in the header. What do I need to edit?

  11. dls says:

    Let me rephrase that… I’ve found #header in the css which increases the size of the full title but I would like to get something like

    Title part Atitle part b

    in other words BIG FONT…little font

    thoughts?

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi DLS,

      If you add some CSS to the ‘Custom CSS’ field on the ‘Edit Basic Simplicity’ page you can change the font size in the header. For example:

      #header h1 { font-size: 20px; }
      #header .description { font-size: 14px; font-weight:bold;}

      To change the color of the text you need to do something slightly different because the blog title is linked:

      #header h1 a { font-size: 20px; color:#000000; }

      Does that make sense?

  12. Andrew says:

    I like you theme!
    Trying to get it set up with my friend’s business logo for the header…It needs to be wider for it all to fit, seems like that should be an easy fix, right? Any hints? I don’t know that much about CSS.

    Andrew

  13. Andrew says:

    Well, I managed to get that fixed to some degree, but is there a way to center the img now. I tried putting “center” instead of “left no-repeat” at the header code are but it didn’t seem to work. Thanks for any help!

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Try this in the ‘Custom CSS’ field on the ‘Edit Basic Simplicity’ page.

      #header { background: #ffffff url(‘http://angelicasgarden.net/wp-content/themes/basic-simplicity/images/securedownload3.jpg’) center no-repeat; }

  14. Cathy Miller says:

    Hi Michael:

    I love your theme. It’s still a work in progress but I do love it. Question–how can I eliminate the date in each post. I might also want to eliminate the “Posted by.”

    Also, I adjusted the font. I like the result in my 1st 2 posts but the font went really small in my most recent post (the poll). I didn’t change anything between posts so I don’t know why that happened. I tried to adjust but it just wasn’t working.Suggestions Thanks.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Cathy,

      It looks like you added a style in the wordpress text editor which negated the style in the stylesheet.

      To remove things like the posted by and date you’ll need to edit the template itself. Go to appearance > editor and select index.php on the right. Scroll down to the line:

      Posted < ?php if(is_page()) {}else{ ?>< ?php the_time('F jS, Y') ?>< ?php } ?> by < ?php the_author() ?> < ?php if(is_page()) { ?>< ?php }else{ ?>and filed in < ?php the_category(', ') ?>< ?php } ?> < ?php edit_post_link('Edit', ' | ', ''); ?>

      Then remove the parts you don’t want.

      The date: < ?php the_time('F jS, Y') ?>

      The Author: by < ?php the_author() ?>

      If you want to remove both on that line you might also want to remove the word “Posted”

  15. Shelisa says:

    I am very new to blogging and have no real technical skill. Can you please explain where I would go to to change the header picture. I am so lost! I am only familiar with the upload header themes(easy) Thanks

    Shelisa

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Using FTP software upload your photo to wp-content/themes/basic-simplicity/images/

      Then enter the name of the file on the Appearance > Edit Basic Simplicity page.

  16. Cathy Miller says:

    Thanks, Michael. I’ll play around with it but I didn’t make a change between the 2nd & the 3rd post so that’s why I don’t get why it suddenly changed font size.

    I did change the HTML for the last post to make the font size bigger on the last post only after it was very small font. I may revert back to your original as I didn’t make a ton of changes. Fingers crossed it works. :-)

  17. Jane Kirsch says:

    Hi Michael: Thanks so much for this theme – it is just what I was looking for! I am an intermediate level geek in site design and have had some challenges getting it to look like I want but they’ve each been a valuable lesson.

    The one problem that remains is that I can’t find the files for the widget boxes to change the way the content appears in them. If you look at my site, the categories, archives and blogroll are all parked to the left of the sidebar column- can I move them to center somehow?

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Jane,

      #sidebar is wrapped around the entire sidebar so any styles applied to it would change the entire sidebar. for example:

      #sidebar {text-align:center;}

      .sidebar-widget is wrapped around each widget. styling this would style each widget and have essentially the same effect. for example:

      .sidebar-widget {text-align:center;}

      If you want the text aligned left but pushed to the left a little more you could try something like:

      .sidebar-widget { width:300px; margin-right:20px;}

      Did that help of confuse things more?

  18. I love the simplicity of your website and the nice utility you included to customize certain elements. My wife, however, wants her logo to be taller. Is this an option in your theme or is completely fixed. I understand that it would probably result in some vertical scrolling as a result, but she’s the boss. Thanks, man.

  19. andrew says:

    Thanks Michael, but it didn’t work. Now there is no image. That’s weird. Any other advice? Thanks in advance.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      That would be a bug :-) I need to fix that.

      I’ll send you the updated file in a little bit (and upload it to wordpress)

  20. Hey, that worked. Awesome.
    My favorite thing about the WordPress site is that you built a utility that allows customization. That’s very convenient for people who’d rather blog than code.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Thanks Brad… yeah that was me too! I got tired of editing other people’s themes and decided to go simple and build the ability to quickly customize for each of my blogs. Glad you like it!

  21. I been using your theme for awhile. Now I am combining my website and blog together using WordPress and want to know how to eliminate the posted date and by author on pages only with your theme? I still want those to show on posts

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Bruce,

      I’ll work on the sample code for that but it will require an edit to the index.php page found at Appearance > Editor and then pick index.php

      Also… I just posted a new version of Basic Simplicity. The only two things existing users will need to know is that the header image path is handled differently and if you’ve edited files like the index.php page you’ll need to backup your old copy first so you can go back and make those edits again.

      -Michael

      http://www.basicsimplicity.com/

  22. Carlos Perez says:

    I downloaded your theme earlier this week and love it! It was exactly what I was looking for. And I see you’ve been very patient and helpful with people’s questions.

    I do have one that may not necessarily be an issue with the theme. Although I’ve changed various colors through your customization utility as well as on the css style sheet, those changes still don’t show up when I reload my pages. I’ve tried this at home and at work, and still the old changes I made yesterday show up although I’ve changed things today.

    Also, I get a different look if I type in the ‘www.’ prefix to the url as opposed to leaving this out. Do you know why this might be?

    And thanks again for your great work!

    -C

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Carlos,

      Two things come to mind first. The first is that any edits to style.css (the stylesheet) may get overridden by the data in the form. Basically the form adds styles, a second stylesheet if you will. View source and you’ll see it in the page between the style tags.

      The other thing is a question… are you running WP Super Cache or similar? When style related edits don’t show up it’s usually because you’re looking at a cached (old) page, either in the browser or provided by the server or host. Could this be the case? Different browsers handle caching differently too, for example IE likes to hold onto it’s cached pages harder than say firefox.

      I uploaded a fresh version of the theme too, see http://www.basicsimplicity.com for details on upgrading. It’s still free, just some new features.

  23. Carlos Perez says:

    Wow, quick reply! Originally, I thought it was a cache issue (and still think it is somehow). However, I’ve gone and cleared out my web history and cache on Firebox, Safari, and Explorer and the same problem exists. Plus, I had my girlfriend check out the site from her computer for the first time and she got the same old site colors even though she wouldn’t have had a cached site.

    I don’t know about WP Super Cache but I will update the newest version of the theme. I’ll probably do more research on the wordpress forums.

    Thanks Michael!

    -C

  24. Hi Michael. I’m fairly new to WordPress but have been fiddling quite extensively. Your theme is one of the the nicest and most customisable of the many free ones I’ve looked at. Thank you for putting it out there for us.

    Improvments that I might suggest (I don’t know if its even possible) would be the facility to change the sidebar and post area background colours, and add a bit of space between the sidebar and the content.

    Thanks again!

  25. Judi says:

    Hey Micheal –

    I must say your customer service is BEYOND GREAT!! You answer everyone so promptly — truly amazing in this day and age.

    Like everyone else, I love the site. I’m trying to get my RSS to show more than 10 posts. So I went in to the widget and changed the number to 20, but it stays at 10.

    Is there some way I can fix that?

    Thanks,

    Judi

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Judy,

      Thanks! Yeah I try to respond to all comments/emails. Good blogging practice :-)

      I think that’s the WordPress part and not the theme. It should be controlled at Settings > Reading. I’ll take a look though, but I don’t think anything I coded would force a limit to the RSS feed.

      -Michael

  26. Judi says:

    Hey Michael –

    You were right! I needed to change the WP part — once I got the two in sync — voila! Twenty posts. Yea!

    Thanks a lot!

    Judi

  27. Judith says:

    Hi Michael,
    I love your web site, the nice clean lines and simple use.

    My problem is I really don’t know what I’m doing and how I got as far as I did with it, becuase I’m a novice at this. Can you tell me how to get back into the header and remove or change the generic words: Just another WordPress weblog

    Thanks so much.Judith

  28. Mike,

    We’d like to have the “Add a Comment” appear on some pages but not others. We’ve shut off the “Allow Comments” checkbox on some of the pages, but the “Add a Comment” remains but doesn’t do anything. Any easy way to remove it from the screen on some pages but not others? Thanks.

    Brad M.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Brad,

      The link “Add a Comment” should actually say “Comments off” when the comments are turned off for that page or post. Does it still say “Add a Comment”?

      The message “Comments off” is built into wordpress but there is a way to edit the index.php file (Appearance > Editor, select index.php on the right). Begin by opening that index file in the wordpress editor.

      Then look for this line of code

      <div class="meta-addcomment"><?php comments_popup_link(‘Add a Comment’, ’1 Comment’, ‘% Comments’, ‘commentslink’); ?></div>

      and replace it with this:

      <?php if ( comments_open() ) : ?>
      <div class="meta-addcomment"><?php comments_popup_link(‘Add a Comment’, ’1 Comment’, ‘% Comments’, ‘commentslink’); ?></div>
      <?php else : // comments are closed ?>
      <!– nothing –>
      <?php endif; ?>

      Keep a fresh unzipped copy of Basic Simplicity handy (or a backup of the index.php file) in case something breaks. Nothing should break but anytime you mess with the php tags in the templates you run the risk of breaking the theme.

      I hope that helps!

      -Michael

  29. Dev says:

    Hi Michael. I am also a fan of your Basic Simplicity theme. I just started to use it and decided to keep it. I can’t tell you how many themes I have tried and discarded.

    I’m still new to WordPress themes and working with CSS.

    Question about the footer: I added my name after the . It appears on the blog, but now the footer.php code in ‘edit themes’ has disappeared. The box is blank, and the update file button has disappeared. Any reason for this?

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Dev,

      I have no idea why that would happened. I can see the footer on your site, so the footer.php must have code in it. Not sure why it’s not showing up in the editor.

  30. Michael,

    I know how to make a page the static front page or the page that has all the posts, but is it possible to have the front page contain all the posts AND have some static HTML above it? Specifically, we want to have a self-running slideshow appear above the newest post, and as each new post is created, that one becomes the top post. No doubt I can find a plug-in that’ll give me the slide show, but is it possible to create a front page that combines static and dynamic elements? Thanks, man. Keep up the good work.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Brad,

      If you find a plugin like that with a widget you’ll be able to drag the widget into the Home-Top space (Appearance > Widgets).

      Then below it you’ll have you regular posts. You can see an example of this (using the tags widget) on http://mikejanzen.com

      -Michael

  31. Judi says:

    Hi Mike –

    I love this theme. It is perfect for what I am doing.

    But one thing I noticed and it’s freaking me out is when someone posts a comment that I accept, the comment shows on the site with their name – followed by date, time and (Edit). If you click on Edit, you get returned to my WP-Admin site to Edit the comment! OMG – so scary! I want to take the date off and I definitely want to get the EDIT capability off.

    I’ve searched your code and cannot find it. Do you know if WP has something I can change?

    Thanks so much!

    Judi

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Judi,

      The “Edit” link only shows to Admin’s when they are logged in. Visitors to the site do not see that link.

      The date and name can be hidden by adding a style to the Custom CSS field (Appearance > Edit Basic Simplicity)

      .comment-author {visibility: hidden;}

      -Michael

  32. Judi says:

    You are GOOD!

    Thanks for the quick response!

    Judi

  33. Dev says:

    Hi Michael. The footer code “disappearance” seemed to resolve itself. I was away from the site for more than a week, and when I logged in to make an update, the footer code was back. Thank you for checking for me. I can’t tell you how many people love the site. I appreciate all the work that you have done on this wordpress theme.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Thanks Dev.

      It looks like you are running the Google Analytics plugin from Yoast so you don’t need to add your Google Analytics code to the field on the Edit Basic Simplicity page (Appearance > Edit Basic Simplicity). I suspect that may be messing it up because the Google Analytics code is in the page twice.

      When adding Google Analytics code to the Edit Basic Simplicity page be sure to use the full javascript code Google provides. But you probably know that… just wanted to add since it may help others.

      -Michael

      -Michael

  34. joecmn says:

    Thank you Michael for the hardwork that you have put on this theme. Can you tell me how to make the menu like drop down list?
    Regards,
    Joe

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Joe. That is a feature I’ve not planned to add. It requires adding some javascript and css as well as some edits to the html that surrounds the lists wordpress generates at the top. You might look for some plugins that so similar things.

  35. Mike F says:

    Hi Michael:

    Are you still there?

    I’m new to WordPress and your theme (Basic Simplicity) has been the MOST helpful to me.

    Thanks already.

  36. Mike F says:

    No it’s just that the last post I saw was from Jan.

    A couple of quick questions, though.

    1. If you aren’t already wealthy from having shared all this knowledge, I’d like to get a small donation to you.

    2. Is there a search feature on the Basic Simplicity theme or did I not look thoroughly?

  37. Mike F says:

    Hi Michael:

    I’m still working on my site. Thanks to you, I feel like I’m getting somewhere.

    HOWEVER, I have a question for which you might have an answer:

    I’d like ONE of my pages to look like a blog. That is, I’d like it to have tags underneath the posts.

    If you’d like to check out the site, it’s http://www.precisiontextediting.com

    The page I’d like to look like a blog is the one called “Writing Help.”

    You’ll see that people apparently ARE able to comment, but there are no tags under the first post.

    I might have other questions, and I’m more than willing to pay you for your time!

    Thanks so much.

  38. Michael Janzen says:

    Mike,

    So you want to hide tags etc on most pages. Right now I use a built in WordPress function called is_page() to show and hide things between posts and pages.

    There are more conditional functions you could use to customize your blog. http://codex.wordpress.org/Conditional_Tags

    See the section on Pages called ‘A PAGE Page’ and not the section on posts.

    You’ll find things like:
    is_page()
    When any Page is being displayed.
    is_page(’42′)
    When Page 42 (ID) is being displayed.
    is_page(‘About Me And Joe’)
    When the Page with a post_title of “About Me And Joe” is being displayed.
    is_page(‘about-me’)
    When the Page with a post_name (slug) of “about-me” is being displayed.

    I think you could make a little conditional statement in the index.php file in the theme to show the tags etc for just one page.

  39. Mike F says:

    Wow.

    Maybe this question might have a simpler answer since the above is pretty complex (by my low standards):

    Is there a way to rename the HOME page to something else (ie, Writing Help)?

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Mike… yes that’s an easy one.

      Open Appearance > Editor and then header.php over on the right side of the screen under ‘Theme Files’.

      Find this line:

    • “>< ?php _e("Home"); ?>
    • Change it to:

    • “>Writing Help
    • Then make your ‘Writing Help’ page a post instead.

      Does that accomplish what you’re trying to do?

      -Michael

  • Mike F says:

    Well it “worked” in that it changed the words on the button, but since I have “We’re Different” as my landing page, it still sent me there.

    You said, “Then make your ‘Writing Help’ page a post instead.”

    That’s the part I can’t seem to do.

    I feel guilty for taking so much of your time.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Mike… no worries about the time… I really am happy to help.

      The easiest way to change a page to a post is simply to copy and paste the content into a post. Posts > Add New. Then to keep it at the top of the homepage make it ‘Sticky’ (see the right side of the ‘Add new’ page.

  • Mike F says:

    I think I’ve come up with at least a temporary fix…

  • Mike F says:

    I’ll try you most recent suggestion in a bit. Need a break!

  • Mike F. says:

    Hi Michael:

    1. How do I activate the links in the sidebar?
    2. How do I remove the words “Add a Comment” from each page under the page title?
    3. How do I (or can I) make the sidebar a little more narrow?

    Thanks!

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Activate links in sidebar? Do you mean drag the links widget into the sidebar? Appearance > Widgets.

      Add a Comment can be turned off for each post on the add post page (Posts > Add New). It can be turned off at the site level on Settings > Discussion. It can also be removed from the theme by going to Appearance > Editor, then select index.php on the right. Look for this line of code and remove it or comment it out.
      <div class="meta-addcomment"><?php comments_popup_link(‘Add a Comment’, ’1 Comment’, ‘% Comments’, ‘commentslink’); ?></div>

      Editing the width of the sidebar is tricky and I don’t recommend it. You’d need to edit the main stylesheet, Appearance > Editor, then select style.css. Before making changes be sure to note that it’s perfectly sizes for 300×250 banners.

  • Jennifer says:

    I have one question for you, is there a way to change the number of posts that show up on the home page? I would like about 5 but not sure where the code would be to change that.

    Thanks for your time

  • Mike F. says:

    SOLVED links.

    Hope you haven’t already spent time on it…

    Still need to remove “Add a Comment”

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Add a Comment can be turned off for each post on the add post page (Posts > Add New). It can be turned off at the site level on Settings > Discussion. It can also be removed from the theme by going to Appearance > Editor, then select index.php on the right. Look for this line of code and remove it or comment it out.

      < ?php comments_popup_link(‘Add a Comment’, ‘1 Comment’, ‘% Comments’, ‘commentslink’); ?>
  • Mike says:

    Did my questions disappear, or am I not tracking this thing properly?

  • Mike says:

    Thanks so much as always.

    A couple more IF you’re up to it today.

    Does it violate protocol to remove the words “WordPress” and the name of your theme? I’d still leave your name with the link.

    I guess I want it to BE a wordpress site without it looking too much like it IS a wordpress site.

    Hopefully not too many more questions.

    Thanks and God bless.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Feel free to do what you please with your site. I’m always happy to have a backlink but its your site and I respect anyones decision to edit their footer as they see fit.

  • Judi says:

    Hey Super Michael —

    I always read every comment and reply so I don’t ask you a question you’ve already answered and as always am so impressed with your extreme customer service!!

    Is there some way I can remove the date from my sticky post? I’d like the dates to remain on other posts since I update almost every day and I want people to know the content is new and relevant.

    It’s just the sticky post I’d like the date to be gone — or better yet, auto update to today’s date so it looks like it’s fresh!

    Thanks,

    Judi

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Thanks Judi.

      I’ve not tried using this but there is a WordPress function called is_sticky()
      http://codex.wordpress.org/Conditional_Tags

      You might try adding a little code around the date in the index.php file (Appearance > Editor, then see index.php on the right). For example, find this line of code:

      <div>Posted <?php the_time(‘F jS, Y’) ?> by <?php the_author() ?> <?php if(is_page()) { ?><!–nothing–><?php }else{ ?>and filed in <?php the_category(‘, ‘) ?><?php } ?> <?php edit_post_link(‘Edit’, ‘ | ‘, ”); ?></div>

      and replace it with:

      <div><?php if(is_sticky()){ }else{ ?>Posted <?php the_time(‘F jS, Y’) ?> by <?php the_author() ?> <?php if(is_page()) { ?><!–nothing–><?php }else{ ?>and filed in <?php the_category(‘, ‘) ?><?php } ?><?php } ?> <?php edit_post_link(‘Edit’, ”, ”); ?></div>

      That will also remove the category in addition to the date but leave the edit link if you’re logged in as admin.

  • Mike says:

    Hi again Michael:

    A couple last things (yeah right)…

    1. Can I change the year of the copyright? If so, how. (We’ve been in business since 2008 and I don’t want it to look like a rookie’s site.)

    2. Atop my posts (like the one you’ll see if you go to precisiontextediting.com) , it says “and filed in College Writing” (or whatever the category is). How do I get rid of that?

    3. Finally, I want people to be able to contact me via email. I want the word “contact” to link directly to the email address. Is that possible? Seems like when I tried to make a link in the regular way, it didn’t connect to an email.

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Hi Mike.

      You can edit the copyright by editing the footer.php file (Appearance > Editor, on the right click footer.php.) I think the correct way to show that is 2008-2010… or more accurately (FirstYear – CurrentYear)

      You can edit the “filed in category” by editing the index.php file. (Appearance > Editor, on the right click index.php). Scroll down and you’ll spot that text between some PHP code.

      I use a plugin called Contact Form 7 which has you make a page and imbed a tiny bit of code they provide. The page link then shows up in the nav bar in Basic Simplicity.

      If you wanted to hard code an email link in the nav bar just edit the header.php file (Appearance > Editor, then click header.php on the right.) Scroll down to the navbar area and add a list item

    • email link here
  • Mike says:

    Hi Michael:

    A question that may or may not be related to your theme:

    None of my pages is “approved.”

    1. Who does the approving?
    2. How do they do it?
    3. Does it matter?

    • Michael Janzen says:

      Sounds like you’re talking about the status of a post or page. Look in the top right part of the ‘Add New’ post/page screen and select published.

  • Leave a Reply